Often, evaluations are organized by criteria. You decide which criteria are appropriate for the subject and audience, and then you use those criteria to outline the essay. Your first few paragraphs of introduction establish your thesis or overall claim and then give background information: what the subject is, why gettysburg address and i have a dream comparison essay are evaluating it, what the competition is, and how you gathered your data.
Then you order the criteria according to some plan: chronological order, spatial order, order of importance, or another logical sequence. Chinese restaurants today, and overall claim: The Hunan Dynasty is reliable, a good value, and versatile. Hunan Dynasty has, despite an occasional glitch, expert service. Main dishes at Hunan Dynasty are generally good but not often memorable. Concluding paragraphs: Hunan Dynasty is a top-flight neighborhood restaurant. Books, films, restaurants, courses, music, writers, scientists, historical events, sports — all can be evaluated using comparison and contrast. Cameron compares two restaurants, the Unicorn and the Yakitori, on the basis of her first criterion — an atmosphere that seemed authentically oriental.
Of the two restaurants, we preferred the authentic atmosphere of the Unicorn to the cultural confusion at the Yakitori. At first impression, the Yakitori looked like a converted truck-stop, sparsely decorated with a few bamboo slats and Japanese print fabric hanging in slices as Bruce Springsteen wailed loudly in the ears of the customers. The feeling at the Unicorn was quite the opposite as we entered a rcom that seemed transported from Chinatown. The whole room had a red tint from the light shining through the flowered curtains, and the place looked truly authentic from the Chinese patterned rug on the wall to the elaborate dragon on the ceiling. Thesis: Although several friends recommended the Yakitori, we preferred the Unicorn for its more authentic atmosphere, courteous service, and well-prepared food.
Cameron might have used a block comparison-and-contrast structure for her essay. Comments on Lucas’s previous film, American Graffiti. Evaluation of the climax of the film. Comment on the viewer’s good feelings at the end of the film. Works of art or performances, for example, oftenjneasure the effect on the viewers or audience. Judgment: The iconography, or use of symbols, contributes to the powerful effect of this picture on the viewer. Evidence: The church as a symbol of hopefulness contrasts with the cruelty of the execution.
The spire on the church emphasizes for the viewer how powerless the Church is to save the victims. Judgment: The use of light contributes to the powerful effect of the picture on the viewer. Evidence: The light casts an intense glow on the scene, and its glaring, lurid, and artificial qualities create the same effect on the viewer that modern art sometimes does. Evidence: The diagonal lines scissor the picture into spaces that give the viewer a claustrophobic feeling.